Market Gardening and Catching Carbon

After driving all night from my North Georgia market gardens I arrived just before seven in the morning at the Indianapolis hotel where the ACRES U.S.A. Convention was to be held. The lines at the hotel desk were so long I left my colleague, Lorraine Cahill, to check in while I headed for the restaurant. I needed a steaming mug of coffee and a bite of breakfast to start my day. Otherwise I was in danger of fading away. Growing market veggies for 26 weeks for restaurants, markets and box subscribers had, thankfully, just come to a close before driving all night to reach America’s most unforgettable and inspiring convention. I didn’t want to miss a minute of it, but I had a booth to set up when the trade show opened and I needed more push than I had at the moment.

As fate would have it, as I joined the cue the people in front of me were Gary Zimmer from Wisconsin, Roelf Havinga from the Netherlands and a man named Rex (whose last name eludes my recall) from South Africa. We struck up conversation and all took a table together in the packed restaurant. I was the last one at my table through the buffet line, and as I took my seat I ventured that I figured the single highest priority we had as ecological farmers was to maximize the carbon we took out of the atmosphere and stored in the soil. After all, we, and all the things we grew on our farms, were carbon based life forms. “Funny you should mention that,” said Rex. “That’s precisely what I tell all my clients.”

Roelf echoed Rex’s sentiments with “You sure have got that right. When we store carbon in our soil we build life into our farms. I am all the time telling people this.”

The irrepressible Gary, who can say more in less time than all three Marx brothers talking at once, then regaled us with details of the whats, whys, hows, whos whens and the importance of catching carbon. “You can’t build soil without carbon, and the crazy thing about it is carbon is free. It’s the single most important thing a farmer can do. It’s a pity we cow farmers are demonized for releasing methane when growing grass and grazing it puts more carbon in the soil than anything else you can do.”

I had to agree with Gary that savvy graziers caught carbon more easily than any other type of farmer. The single biggest riddle I’d had to solve in self-sufficient biodynamic market gardening was how to build carbon into the soil whilst cultivation returned so much to the atmosphere. I’d discovered I had to maintain a grass and legume sod, almost as robust as my pastures, on all my traffic paths as well as growing robust mixes of the most productive crops I could find for my rotations. For those veggies like cukes, potatoes, capsicums, tomatoes, squash and ginger, mulch was the answer; but either way I had to keep the soil as fully covered as much of the time as I could, and I had to find ways of cultivation that minimized compaction and soil structure destruction.

After a delicious breakfast and lively discussion we got on with our day, each agreeing that being a good farmer meant catching carbon, first, foremost and always.

It should be no secret that excessive cultivation ranks right up there with mono-cropping and use of chemical nitrogen for driving carbon out of the soil and killing it; and yet, cultivation is what even the best organic and biodynamic market gardeners do. The trick is to not be excessive. Here is a picture of the method of cultivation I worked out. By cultivating metre wide beds between my tractor tyres and growing a mix of grass, clover and forbs on my driving strips I created heaps of edges—so beloved by observant permaculturists—whilst my paths were my biological reservoirs. There was never any spot in the field more than half a metre away from a rich diversity of plants and animals, small and not so small.

Maize or sweet corn, interplanted with soybeans, was my favourite way of catching carbon in summer. In winter it was cereal rye interplanted with a winter annual clover such as crimson clover, though I’m told arrowleaf clover or fenugreek are well suited to Australian conditions. In this mix I would also plant turnips, mustard greens, Chinese winter radishes and rape. Incidentally, corn salad, which used to grow in all winter grain paddocks, is an annual valerian that solubilises phosphorous and is known in German lore as rapunzel. The turnips, radishes and greens I harvested for market, as—like most folks—I needed a payday. The corn salad is a beloved and medicinal spring salad greens, and the grain can be cut for mulch at milk stage in the spring when it boots. Once the soil becomes crumbly and full of life, tomatoes, capsicums or cucurbits can be planted directly into the stubble with a spade—which is a pointed shovel—but don’t ever walk on the beds!

As for maize, the growing season is fairly long and earthworm populations would decline without mowing the paths for earthworm tucker about midway through the maize cycle. Earthworm populations need to be kept high in order to digest the thick stalks and soybean vines over winter after the rye is planted. Only the maize or sweet corn ears are picked, following the rule that if you want to build carbon you never export more than 8% of your biomass production. The spader pictured above has a beautiful tossing action that keeps the organic matter in the top two or three inches with just enough soil on top to plant the rye and clover mix into. The mass of maize stalks and soy vines need to be finely mowed before spading or the spader can’t chew them; but what a wealth of carbon is incorporated into the topsoil for moist, aerobic, fungal digestion! Fungal breakdown produces glomalin, which builds structural carbon into the soil.

Nitrogen management is another key. Loose, salty nitrogen burns carbon. It is the waste product of nitrogen fixing microbes, and when the soil is awash in it nitrogen fixers tend to feel like they are drowning in a dysfunctional septic tank. They say “That’s it. We’re out of here.”

What sets them on a nitrogen fixing jag is sugars. Then they produce amino acids that end up getting tied up with carbon in stable proteins in the soil reserve. On healthy soils that could easily be 3 or 4,000 ppm as stable protein nitrogen. Dumping something like raw chicken manure on the soil makes these beneficials give up the ghost and a protein breakdown cascade sets in. Then your soil loses carbon at a scary rate. Some estimate that 100 parts of carbon can be lost for every part of salt nitrogen added.

Also something else occurs—weeds. Unlike big seeds such as maize, beans and cereals, weed seeds generally are quite tiny. They depend on the soil being awash with soluble NPK and other nutrients. Their role in nature is to sop this up and conserve it. When it’s there they take off and outpace large seeded crops. Thus savvy farmers do not want much soluble nitrogen in the soil when they plant. They want nitrogen fixers to come running when large seeds start sprouting and excrete their carbs into the soil. Then there will be abundant amino acid nitrogen—all within a centimetre or so of the roots of the crop plants—while next to none will be available to the weeds even if they sprout. The picture just above shows maize with soybean at 21 days after planting.

Close inspection shows plenty of weeds which can’t get beyond the cotyledon stage because they don’t have any carbs to feed the nitrogen fixers, and they don’t have enough free nitrogen in the soil. This is an example of good nitrogen management in a vibrantly healthy living soil with plenty of nitrogen fixers living in it. And good nitrogen management is how to catch carbon and build it into the soil—even in a market garden.

To summarize, building soil carbon—the foremost imperative of every ecological grower—requires minimal, non-destructive cultivation. It also requires maximum diversity so the ecology is robust. It also requires good nitrogen management, which means keeping soluble nitrogen to a minimum and keeping plenty of nitrogen fixers alive in cultivated areas. This in turn means minimizing areas and times the soil is left bare. This also means NOT tilling in green matter which will decay and release soluble nitrogen.

And lest we forget, you want aerobic, fungal breakdown if you mix dry matter, like corn stalks, into the soil. This means you never incorporate organic matter deeply—even if it is dry—because you want fungi breakdown to make glomalin, build stable carbon and create superb soil structure.



One thought on “Market Gardening and Catching Carbon

  1. Great article! It really helped to clarify the biology/chemistry behind a number of practises. Now I understand more about the importance of timing in nitrogen management, the proper care and feeding of earthworms, etc. Fascinating!!

    Before I began studying permaculture, I worked on a watershed management plan in Southern Califoria for a water body that receives a great deal of agricultural runoff. The agricultural “experts” told us, “As long as there a winter row crops” (winter being the rainy season), “there will be nitrogen runoff”, resulting in excess nitrogen in the river. And I believed them! Now I’m learning that doesn’t have to be the case. There are other ways to manage row crops that could considerably reduce “excess nitrogen” in stormwater runoff from the fields. Thank you for sharing your experience and knowledge with us.-Sunny

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *